There are many examples of representations of non-musical sounds finding their way into classical music. Perhaps, the most famous example is that of the thunderstorm in the Fourth Movement of Ludwig von Beethoven’s Sixth Symphony named the “Pastoral.” [PLAY 6TH SYMPONY EXCERPT] Notice how the loud crashes of the orchestra seem to replicate the crash of thunder while the drums also seem to simulate the rumbling of the thunder. Storms were in fact one of the most popular examples of non-musical sounds used in 19th century classical music. They can be found in Rossini’s “William Tell Overture”, Berlioz’s “Symphonie Fantastique” and Musorgsky’s “Night on Bald Mountain.” And indeed there are other sounds from nature that can be found in other pieces. Both Mendelsohn, in his “Scottish Symphony,” and Wagner in his “Flying Dutchman Overture” orchestrated sounds that are very reminiscent of tides rising and falling on seashores.
Of course these examples all come from nature, which was definitely a good source of material from this time period as the industrial revolution was just about to start and the machines that would later influence the music of 20th century composers had yet to be built. However, it is my belief that composers from the 18th and 19th centuries were also influenced by sounds that were even closer to home, so to speak. After listening to classical music for most of my life, I believe I have found examples of composers who were influenced by human sounds
The first two examples I would like to play are by Joseph Haydn and Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. These two were contemporaries and they composed their music at the end of the 19th century. However, Haydn, a truly prodigious composer, is known as the father of the modern symphony. Here’s an example from his Symphony No. 101. Listen towards the end of this excerpt for a short section where the strings oscillate back and forth between low and high notes [PLAY HAYDN 101]. This oscillation is much easier to hear in this next example from Mozart’s Symphony No. 41 [PLAY MOZART 41].
So what do these short sections of music represent? It is my belief that both composers are imitating the sound of breathing. The high notes are the inhales and the low notes are the exhales. The fact that in both examples this particular sequence of notes is repeated several times lends support to the theory. In addition, there are also examples of music by 20th century composers, such as Benjamin Britten, who uses something called a “breathing motif,” so the possibility that earlier composers did the same thing may not be unfounded. Listen again to the Mozart and see if you can hear the breathing in the music when that section comes up [PLAY MOZART 41].
Now Mozart was no stranger to using human sounds in his compositions. Here is a much more famous example from Mozart’s Requiem. However, this time the example is not of breathing but of sobbing. [PLAY MOZART REQUIEM]. This composition, which is believed to be the last piece of music Mozart ever composed, has been studied closely for a long time. Many musicologists and musicians have described the sounds coming from the strings as sobbing. The reason why they may be correct is because the name of this particular movement from the Requiem is “Lacrimosa,” which means tears in Latin.
Moving ahead, we now return to Beethoven. He came right after Haydn and Mozart and in fact Haydn was one of his teachers. His two predecessors heavily influenced him. However, once Beethoven had learned the forms and styles of his day, he went about transforming them in some rather ingenious ways. Nevertheless, one can still find many examples of “breathing” in his music. Here’s one example from Beethoven’s 3rd Piano Concerto [PLAY BEETHOVEN 3RD]. The breathing, if that’s what it is, is remarkably clear and can also be found in many other pieces by Beethoven such as his 2nd and 4th Symphonies and his 19th Piano Sonata.
But are these really examples of breathing? Couldn’t they simply be examples of a popular musical device of that time? The answer to the second question is of course yes. Perhaps, these sounds are merely coincidences. Or perhaps, these composers were just unknowingly influenced by the sound of breathing. The truth is we’ll never know for sure. As far as I know there are no written records explaining these particular musical devices and we can’t simply call up Haydn, Mozart or Beethoven and ask them. However, the real reason why I think this hypothesis may be correct is because it is part of a larger one that I have regarding classical music. I believe that there are strong connections between the sound of speech and classical music. I cannot prove that yet, but it is definitely something I want to explore further. All I have to go on now are examples like the ones I’ve just presented and a gut intuition that I’m on to something.
Before I end my presentation, though, I would like to play one last example of breathing [PLAY TRIO SONATA]. This time I can tell you exactly what was going through this composer’s mind when he composed this piece. As it was, this composer wasn’t thinking about breathing when he put down these notes, he was in fact, just using them as a musical device. How do I know that for certain? Well, this piece is called the Trio Sonata in B minor for Flute, Cello and Piano and I am the composer. Thank you.