ITPcorkboard
url: http://stu.itp.nyu.edu/~ks2407/ITPcorkboard/
PLANNING
Discuss the project’s overall philosophic goals.
Our overall project goal is to encourage online and offline conversation and collaboration. In a project driven manner.
What is it trying to accomplish in the world?
An organization of the useful information on the ITP list (but without the list)
A lot of social stuff is on the list, but there’s so much happening on the floor project wise where ppl aren’t aware of
This would be a space to ask for collabo, critique, and have a space for conversations around projects your’e involved in
functional like the icm and pcomp list
Identify what problem space they have decided to take on within that goal.
not being able to know what’s going on (more accurately and conveniently)
Assuming the project is transactional, not informational, what mental model of interaction are they using?
corkboard
How literal or abstract is their mental model?
very literal
Is the use of their interactive “handles” and cues obvious or does it or do they require overt instructions?
Different colors represent different types of post
Needs to be used before understanding what the colors mean
Looks random
Does the project use persuasion to get it’s point across, or does it resort to telling it’s users what to do?
Its uses curiosity
What are the sample personas your clients imagine using this project?
-Carlin who doesn’t come to the floor often and read the ITP list at all but who’s curious about other students’ projects
What scenarios do they image them going through?
it varies from ITP students to others like professors/adjucnts/residents or total outsiders
post something or just browse
What cognitive process is this interface attempting to support?
Posting and reading posts on a physical corkboard. Curiosity.
Problem Solving / Learning
REQUIREMENTS
Find examples of people who fall into the types of personas that your client has indicated are their target users.
Carlin (persona #1)
doesn’t use list
curious as to what’s happening on floor
reaches out on the list
may not like being on the floor
Rader/Colombo/Spike
people who are always on the floor
very vocal presence on the list (and floor)
Gabby Levine
On the floor a good amount
not super social
regular presence on floor
Find out their Goals, Frustrations, and Motivations in relation to this type of interaction.
Goals
Spark conversations/awareness around projects happening on the floor
Fun/Creative expression
Frustrations
Making it visually appealing
Photos might not make people post even more
Getting people to notice it
Getting more people to post to it
Motivations
Get noticed by other people
Get help by other people
FORMATIVE EVALUATION
Complete a thorough Heuristic Test of the project’s interface.
Use Neilsen’s 10 Usability Heuristics and your Interface Design Manual to ferret out potential design issues.
Usability Test
Create your questions for a usability test. Remember to include your disclaimer, background questions, overall impression questions and short answer questions, and most importantly, your walk through and wishlist questions.
Test 5 users (formative evaluation)
See below
ANALYSIS
How effective is this tool in accomplishing the creator’s stated philosophic goals?
Fairly successful, just need to get people into posting more.
Where did they succeed and where was there a mismatch?
Getting people to know what’s going on at-a-glance was successful.
Need more participants. People are hesitant to share when it’s not busy.
Does the interface successfully support the cognitive processes that it was created for?
Yes? Could be more organized (colors scheme could be more obvious)
How accurate were the user scenarios that they imagined occurring?
The gist was correct, but there were a lot of unique scenarios that require different things. (eg. partner approval)
How closely did they resemble the actual uses by real users?
Read above.
What Use Cases are missing from the project?
Missing Alumni, residents, teachers, brainstormers (ppl who don’t have a dedicated project idea)
What functionality or abilities does the user want or need to be able to accomplish that are not currently available?
Partner approval, timed posts, sorting by categories/date, personalized feeds
What specific interface problems does the project suffer from?
Posts could be sorted better.
Questions:
Hiye Shin
Have you visited this site before?
No
What do you think the purpose of this site is? (ie. selling, informing, entertainment, etc)
To share an idea.
ITP specific. Seems like a chatroom. Like the list but more public. Less private. For fun.
Who do you think the intended audience is?
ITP students
*Could you tell what the page was about?
This reminds me of post its, put down and idea and put it on the corkboard.
Was anything too obtrusive?
1. I posted a comment to ‘SpiceBox’ and did not register the comment count.
2. When I click the post it bracelet, i was hoping for a picture, but there was no picture. So i was curious abou twhat happens if i click on the title. The title and subtitle are redundant.
Expecting more information
Was anything too well hidden?
More detailed content for each project.
Expecting a photo, or an attached file. (
Problems or kudos on the color scheme?
I really like it in terms of design and color.
Easy to read (both font style and size)?
So far it’s easy to read, but I kind of wonder, if i post another thing, where would it fall and would it end up ont he bottom.
It’s good now at-a-glance, but once there are more posts will have to scroll
How did you find the layout of the site?
Concerns about scrolling
Colors +
I would make the title pop out more
When i click on a post it, the scroll down gets irritating, cuz it pushes everything else down.
The comments section is too large compared to the main ‘article’
How intuitive and helpful is the navigation system?
Main page is intuitive. Right way i got what the purpose is, but it was confusing going into a post it and trying to get details.
Did you notice the search box?
I noticed, but I didn’t notice right away.
It took a good five minutes.
I think they’re for sorting
I’d like it better on top not the bottom, more standard
Did you notice the Post Something?
Noticed the post something right away
What would encourage you to return to this site in the future?
If there is more information, more posts, then it means there are more resources.
Would you use this site to post ideas?
Not this early on, when more popular.
Name your three favorite things about the site, and your three least favorite
Likes:
Post-its
Colors
Layout
Dislikes:
Title
instructions: doing/seeing/reading/thinking (italicized and hard to read)
How often are you on the floor?
Everyday
How often do you post to the list?
Once every two weeks
Just noticed login button?
Confusing – wordpress
ANTONIUS
Have you visited this site before?
I walked past it, but didn’t really interact with it
What do you think the purpose of this site is? (ie. selling, informing, entertainment, etc)
To post what your working on and get input find collaborators and equipment that you would need that you could borrow.
Otherwise browsing and seeing if you could give input or offer equip.
Who do you think the intended audience is?
ITP
Was anything confusion?
The categories are confusing, bcuase there’s a N/A category, and i feel like it needs to be curated.
Some are obvoius, but i think a category should be mandatory
When i click on a person’s name, i don’t want to email them, i want to see what else they’ve done.
I would like to see a user’s history on the site first.
Would n’t mind if there was just an email button. Along side what else they’ve done. More inclined to offer if they are active member of this community.
Was anything hard to find?
Comments section is larger than actual article. My eyes go straight to the comments first. And read that before actual content.
Front page well designed, but once you go in a level, it becomes a lot harder to find description.
I want a way to sort.
Easy to read (both font style and size)?
Fonts good.
How did you find the layout of the site? Color scheme?
Color scheme is great, but not intuitive, I dont know what it means.
I like this layout. Would be better if i kenw what it meant.
Infact, I don’t want to go to a separate page when i click on a post it.
Sort by all the post its of someone’s name
How intuitive and helpful is the navigation system?
It’s great. The best part so far is i can see everything in one page.
I like being able to scroll back down and see th rest of the postits, dont’ ahve to go ‘back’
I would like a ‘read’ option for post-its.
Did you notice the search box? Categories? Post it? Change the way you nav site?
I noticed categories, find it more helpful than search box.
If the search box were uptop, I would use it more often.
Search that sorts relevant to your search query. Keep it all on one page.
What would encourage you to use this site?
It’s such a nonspecific thing, I’m not encouraged to cuz it’s so broad.
Seeing other people’s posts encourages me.
What would encourage you to post to this site?
I was goign to post something, but I wish I could save this as a draft, and let someoen else look at it before posting. Being to time when things go out so it woudl correlate to when you need someting. (boomerang)
How often are you on the floor?
A lot these days. 6 days a week. 7 hours a day.
How often do you post to the list?
Never. Once every semester.
Michella
Have you visited this site before?
No, just seen it on big winow and would post something on
What do you think the purpose of this site is? (ie. selling, informing, entertainment, etc)
Because i’ve used post its before, it hought it was a todo
I thought it was the same thing.
More an ideas thing and to get feed back.
Who do you think the intended audience is?
Students, us? Anyone who is interested int he subject matter that is posted.
Was anything confusion?
No, I thought this was just a synopsis (post it) but when clicking on it, there wasn’t more information.
Was anything hard to find?
Not really
Easy to read (both font style and size)?
It seems okay, not too complicated. The colors i’m not so fond of, but it’s okay easy on the eyes.
How did you find the layout of the site? Color scheme?
Nothing really stands out. Everything looks the same.
How intuitive and helpful is the navigation system?
Did you notice the search box? Categories? Post it? Change the way you nav site?
Arrange thing by the color from post-its.
I didn’t check out categories.
What would encourage you to use this site?
I’m more likely to respond to things that are visually appealing. I would respond to images in place of text.
What would encourage you to post to this site?
Visual appeal color.
How often are you on the floor?
5 days a week, probably more than that. Group projects that bring me to floor.
How often do you post to the list?
Not often. Once every 6 months or 3 months.
Dave Miller
Have you visited this site before?
Yes, posted out front
What do you think the purpose of this site is? (ie. selling, informing, entertainment, etc)
To update people on what other people are doing that you may not talk to all the time.
It’s a cork-board where you have different projects up and potentially get involved with them.
Who do you think the intended audience is?
Us. The ITP people.
Was anything confusion?
1. On add something page. It also has a leave a reply. Which is confusing.
2. It says 1 comment, but there should be another link that says ‘leave a comment’
3. It’s little weir that the comments box rolls the entire page down. But it’s a pretty good setup. Things in order
Was anything hard to find?
Easy to read (both font style and size)?
Font is perfectly find for the amount of text you have.
How did you find the layout of the site? Color scheme?
Wasn’t aware color scheme represented.
The layout is okay. Unsure as to what the order of the post-its are.
How intuitive and helpful is the navigation system? (search/categories)
It’s okay. IT would be nice to color code the menu or what the different thigns are. Or organize things by categoroy. So if theyw ere in columns w/ category heading on top.
Did you notice the search box? Categories? Post it? Change the way you nav site?
Saw them there, but hadn’t thought to use them. It doesn’t seem liek there are more things than i could see at once.
What would encourage you to use this site?
Getting feedback. If you post something and someone posts back.
How often are you on the floor?
Almost every day
How often do you post to the list?
Everyday
Phan
Have you visited this site before?
No
What do you think the purpose of this site is? (ie. selling, informing, entertainment, etc)
Update to what’s going on. Brainstormings, where people chip in ideas and get feedback. Part of a new crit group. Give waht their ideas are. And color coding based on categories.
If people want to collaborate, people can share skills.
Who do you think the intended audience is?
People at school.
Was anything confusion? hard to find?
Going back to home/getting back to the main page.
Is there an ‘offer help page’ (so function of ‘post something’ not obvious)
Easy to read (both font style and size)?
How did you find the layout of the site? font? Color scheme?
As long as you keep it in primary colors. I’m color blind.
I can’t tell the difference. I can see all 4 colors, but for me, if i don’t concentrate, red/green look the same. (so maybe non-color indicator/pattern etc.)
Category/search bar could be moved up, so it brings awareness to different categories.
When you can see ALL the post-its it’s definitely help to have sorting functions.
How intuitive and helpful is the navigation system?
I didn’t know. I thought there shoudl be a header per color/category. (like dave miller said)
Did you notice the search box? Categories? Post it? Change the way you nav site?
Search/categories not obvious until i saw colors changing.
Post something totally makes sense.
What would encourage you to use this site?
If i were to be looking for people to work with or people need help.
A feed relevant to your interests. (personalized feed)
Send alerts
What would encourage you to post to this site?
A little snippet or picture of what people are workign on, and a little gallery withint he post it to get a better idea/get peole excited about project.
How often are you on the floor?
All the time. 5 days of the week.
How often do you post to the list?
Maybe once.
HEURISTICS
Visibility of system status
Organization is not intuitive
Good at a glance feed
Match between system and the real world
Corkboard mental model was easily established.
User control and freedom
Navigation could be more clear. Could use a ‘home’ button.
Have to click on title.
Consistency and standards
Search and category bar was on the bottom rather than top. People expect it to be top right.
Error prevention
Not much room for error.
Recognition rather than recall
Function was straightforward.
Flexibility and efficiency of use
Shallow learning curve, therefore differences btwn exp. and inexp users are too minimal.
Aesthetic and minimalist design
Fairly straightforward.
Some design could have better organizational structure (eg. sorting)
Help users recognize, diagnose, and recover from errors
No real errors.
Help and documentation
Maybe more guidance on the sorting side.
MORE NOTES:
Questions: anonymity?
sorting?
Why this layout:
The diea of winternet wishlist website.
like the layout of ‘theinternetwishlist.com’
- a community corkboard
- harbors conversation
- make it interesting without overdesigning it
- a place to skim
- date relevant feed
- general interest in what other people are doing
- a way to connect with people at ITP you’ve never known
- browsing fun: ‘see all stupid pet tricks’
- good for students and residents. cuz no one really knows what anyone is doing.
- user who doesn’t kow this exists:
- intuitive (hopefully)
- post to the thing your’e here to work
- drop idea and go
- what are ppl working on
- i’m here this afternoon is there someoen i can help out or something i’m interested in
- Carlin: doesnt come on the floor that often, doesn’t read the list
- if carlin was sitting at home and wanted to know what was happening on the floor
- *** what projects do i get out of certain classes
- have knowledge to share
- color coordinaation:
- yellow: just announcing
- blue: need input
- pink: collabo
- green: critique
- multiple colors
- p comp list/icm list
- tones are different
- functions are explicit
- finding something really specific
- FILTER
- kickstarter esque page
Problems:
different levels of commitment i have as a poster