Below is our Google presentation on EcoDollars:
Below is our Google presentation on EcoDollars:
Between the extremes presented by Lerner and Shirky, “For Micro-Money or the Amour”, I land somewhere in the middle.
When you sign up for ComicDrop, you hold 0 ComicCoin, but you don’t know it. This decision is driven by the same forces that illuminate the anecdote about a friend making a code contribution and being pleasantly suprized by a reward granted without expectation. Also, I don’t think I’m a “you have a 100 on the first day of class” kindof guy. Gotta earn that shit.
When a submitted sticker (a shared drawing) is approved, the artist recieves 100 ComicCoin. Approval happens when the drawing is screened to a) be School-Safe and b) not garbage scribbles. You’ll get an email in a day or so letting you know your drawing is accepted and your ComicCoin credited. Hopefully this encourages return visits. Friends* in ComicDrop can see / access your sticker immediately (to foster realtime collaboration).
I want a way for Kids like Karl(tm) to get involved. Therefore – when registered users submit a request/idea for a sticker – they’ll get 50 ComicCoin. These requests will be used as prompts for people with a proclivity to draw but want/could use ideas. These requests are also screened. No notification for successfully submitted requests, but accreditation takes place.
If you draw a requested sticker, you get 150 ComicCoin. Both the person who submitted the idea and the person who fulfilled the request are notified of the successful collaboration.
Once you’ve reached some yet-to-be-determined number of ComicCoin, you can lob a physical thing into the world at a discounted price.
For Example :
Jay has 100 ComicCoin. Jay can order a Mug for 20$, a Postcard for 2.50$, or a Poster for 10$.
Sam has 1000 ComicCoin. Sam can order a Mug for 17$, a Postcard for 1.75$, or a Poster for 7.50$.
This system is therefore not about the popularity of drawings. It does, however, reward taking time to address an unmet/stated want/need. In a system that rewards frequent sticker-reuse, the person who draws a stupid heart will be rewarded. In this system, people are encouraged to stay nimble, stretch creatively, and keep drawing.
Right now, the numbers are fungible, and I’m interested in gathering sentiments re: “what is fair” / how much effort should a discount take.
Additionally, People want a place to feel recognized for their work, and to browse each other’s sticker portfolios – I appreciate that. ComicDrop will have a zone where an individual user’s stickers will be viewable as a collection. Users can give & recieve kudos to one another. Kudos thresholds might exist for bonus discount(s). The idea is that respect and encouragement is earned by making outstanding drawings – unique work that other people feel compelled to tip their virtual hats towards.
ComicCoin earns users a discount on Material made Real. This discount would, in effect, take “my/our” cut. Which is to stay, the profit I would otherwise make when people order physical goods. I.E. a mug on lob costs 17$. If I normally charge 20$, but offer a discount for 1000 ComicCoin, I’m giving someone 3$ for their 7 – 10 Stickers, because they’ve made a contribution that improves ComicDrop for everyone. The discounts, at least to start, will not be “stackable”.
I would be interested in subsidizing printed matter even further, but I would have to see whether / how this is economically feasable. If some people are drawing a ton of stickers and other people are buying a ton of stuff at non-discounted prices, I’d be very interested in exploring stacked discounts as rewards for those superusers.
Down the road, I imagine there are also other potential tasks for people interested in accumulating ComicCoin – tasks like moderation, tagging and sorting.
LazyCoin is a currency that quantifies lack of activity. With LazyCoin, the more you do nothing the more value you create.
For Adam, and anyone else interested in the shan zai manufacturers in China:
This week we began speaking about need-based economic models (food stamps initially, and then other theoretical, fixed value assets). We expanded upon this in thinking of the implications of value based systems upon climate change and the potential for incentivizing economic activity that benefits short term and long term ecological stability.
We thought through several scenarios around the concept of EcoDollars – a value system based on the ecological status of a city/country/region:
1. What if for every purchase you make with EcoDollars for a product, you retain some monetary value, which incentivises you to spend your money on ecologically friendly products.
The core idea here is that we thought about was the infrastructure costs of building higher sea walls, disaster prevention, etc. These are vastly more expensive than incentivizing purchases of ecologically sound products that if purchased en masse, could at least minimize the acceleration of climate change. From a purely fiscal standpoint, it’s more expensive to pay for the aftermath of a Hurricane Sandy etc every decade than incentivizing change in social behavior in aggregate.
2. What if you you has a currency that could be used like a normal currency for everyday transactions but the inflation rates were based, again, on how sustainable a region is doing.
Essentially we are considering an alternative system for taxing companies, but instead of focussing on creating constraints and regulations in the market, we incentivize the public and in essence give them the power to decide how heavily the factories that primarily responsible for environmental problems would be taxed (hypothetically).
Here are some of the questions we have and additional elements of consideration: